Data report · 1 October 2026
Guernsey's idle glasshouses: where they are and what they are worth
Guernsey has 150 glasshouse sites of 500 m² or more, covering 64.1 ha, and the States has never published where they are. This register lists every one; the land could hold about 2,245 homes, but at today's build costs its base-case value is −£282m.
The headline figures
| Measure | Figure | |
|---|---|---|
| Glasshouse sites of 500 m² or more | 150 | mapped in OpenStreetMap |
| Glass on those sites | 64.1 ha | about 391 vergées |
| Homes the land could physically hold | 2,245 | at 35 homes per hectare |
| Value of those homes once built | £1,160m | at today's sold values |
| Residual land value, base case | −£282m | build at £4,000/m², 17.5% developer profit |
| Sites where housing pays for the land | 6 (68 homes) | 77 (992 homes) if build costs £3,500/m² and new homes sell at a 15% premium |
Where the glass is
Half of the mapped glass is in Vale and St Sampson's (32.8 of 64.1 ha), and the 15 largest sites hold 27.0 ha of it.
| Parish | Sites | Glass | Homes it could hold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vale | 46 | 21.3 ha | 746 |
| St Sampson's | 23 | 11.5 ha | 403 |
| Castel | 17 | 6.8 ha | 239 |
| St Saviour | 23 | 6.2 ha | 218 |
| St Peter Port | 5 | 6.2 ha | 216 |
| St Pierre du Bois | 15 | 4.5 ha | 159 |
| St Andrew | 4 | 3.0 ha | 104 |
| St Martin | 6 | 2.0 ha | 68 |
| Torteval | 7 | 1.9 ha | 67 |
| Forest | 4 | 0.7 ha | 25 |
| Site size | Sites | Glass |
|---|---|---|
| 1 ha or more | 15 | 27.0 ha |
| 5,000 m² to 1 ha | 19 | 13.7 ha |
| 2,000 to 5,000 m² | 53 | 16.1 ha |
| 500 to 2,000 m² | 63 | 7.4 ha |
Only 1 of the 561 OpenStreetMap objects is tagged as a ruin, so this shows where glass is, not its condition.
The official figures, and the gap
The States counts 460.7 vergées (75.5 ha) of redundant glass on about 250 sites, plus about 250 cleared sites.
| Figure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Redundant sites with glass still standing (2018 survey) | about 250 | Guernsey Press, 16 Aug 2018 |
| Further cleared former sites, not counted above | about 250 | same survey |
| Redundant glass area (2019 figure) | 460.7 vergées | Bailiwick Express, 4 Jul 2024 |
| The same area, as quoted by the planning president | 75.5 ha | Guernsey Press, 14 Apr 2023 |
| Glass mapped in OpenStreetMap, working and derelict | 67.5 ha, 522 buildings | this register |
The mapped total covers working and derelict glass together, yet sits below the official figure for redundant glass alone. Collapsed or overgrown glass is often not traced as a building, and official redundant-site areas can include yards and hardstanding. The roughly 250 cleared sites cannot appear in the map at all.
Would housing pay for the land?
Values come from this site's sale register. New build on Guernsey is quoted at £4,000 to £6,000/m², while St Sampson's homes sell for about £4,330/m², so private development in the north only pays if build comes in under about £2,350 to £2,860/m². Only St Martin clears the bottom of the quoted range.
| Parish | Homes | Sales value | Land value, base | Land value, optimistic | Break-even build cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vale | 746 | £367m | −£108.3m | −£16.4m | £2,861/m² |
| St Sampson's | 403 | £166m | −£84.7m | −£39.0m | £2,350/m² |
| Castel | 239 | £144m | −£13.5m | +£19.1m | £3,555/m² |
| St Saviour | 218 | £119m | −£22.5m | +£5.7m | £3,191/m² |
| St Peter Port | 216 | £112m | −£27.0m | +£0.3m | £3,020/m² |
| St Pierre du Bois | 159 | £93m | −£11.5m | +£9.8m | £3,432/m² |
| St Andrew | 104 | £54m | −£13.2m | −£0.1m | £3,005/m² |
| St Martin | 68 | £48m | +£1.8m | +£11.9m | £4,205/m² |
| Torteval | 67 | £44m | −£1.1m | +£8.5m | £3,874/m² |
| Forest | 25 | £15m | −£1.7m | +£1.7m | £3,463/m² |
Our reading: this gap is why the glass stays derelict and why the States ends up as the buyer. It paid £6.5m for Kenilworth Vinery in October 2021, £42k to £50k per planned home.
Homes average 95 m². Base build cost is £4,000/m² (pessimistic £5,000; optimistic £3,500 plus a 15% new-build premium), with 10% for roads and drainage, £100/m² of glass for clearance, 5% contingency, 10% fees, 6% finance, 2% sales costs and a 17.5% developer profit. Flood defence, drainage capacity and contamination are not costed.
What has happened to glass sites so far
| Site | Parish | What happened | Scale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Belgrave / Fontaine Vinery | St Sampson's | Affordable housing; framework approved 2025 | 6.26 ha |
| Kenilworth Vinery (Parc Le Lacheur) | Vale / St Sampson's | Housing: 131 planned, now about 154 | 17 vergées; £6.5m |
| Les Abreuveurs | St Sampson's | Ground-mounted solar, about 2.95 MW proposed | glass on about 80% of the site |
| Domarie & Avondale Vineries | St Sampson's | 15 storage units and 2 yards for trades | 12 vergées |
| GROW, Les Petits Quartiers | St Sampson's | Charity horticulture, glass rebuilt on site | £2.5m to £3m project |
| Les Nicolles Vinery | Vale / St Sampson's | Bought by the States for a school or housing | 22.5 acres; £1.7m |
| Rue des Mares vinery | St Pierre du Bois | Clearance plus one house: refused | 1.2 ha |
Our reading: housing and industry approvals cluster in the north near the Bridge; rural western sites get refused and stay derelict.
Planning policy
- Island Development Plan (2016): outside the centres, where most sites sit, redundant glass may be reused for small-scale industry, storage and distribution, a property's curtilage, renewable energy, or camping and outdoor recreation (Carey Olsen, 8 Jun 2018).
- The Strategic Land Use Plan rules most redundant glass out of housing; in 2024 it was not due for review for about seven years (Guernsey Press, 5 Jul 2024).
- Affordable-housing policy GP11 is set to 0% until 31 May 2029 (Collas Crill).
All 150 sites
Largest first. Homes at 35 per hectare; land value is the base-case residual. Each link opens the site on OpenStreetMap.
| Site | Parish | Glass | Homes | Land value, base | Map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | St Peter Port | 38,019 m² | 133 | −£16.6m | Map |
| 2 | Vale | 29,269 m² | 102 | −£14.8m | Map |
| 3 | St Pierre du Bois | 25,882 m² | 91 | −£6.6m | Map |
| 4 | Vale | 22,372 m² | 78 | −£11.3m | Map |
| 5 | Vale | 16,965 m² | 59 | −£8.6m | Map |
| 6 | Castel | 15,983 m² | 56 | −£3.2m | Map |
| 7 | Vale | 15,955 m² | 56 | −£8.1m | Map |
| 8 | St Andrew | 14,830 m² | 52 | −£6.6m | Map |
| 9 | Vale | 14,801 m² | 52 | −£7.5m | Map |
| 10 | St Sampson's | 14,352 m² | 50 | −£10.5m | Map |
| 11 | St Sampson's | 14,346 m² | 50 | −£10.5m | Map |
| 12 | St Peter Port | 12,712 m² | 44 | −£5.5m | Map |
| 13 | St Sampson's | 12,410 m² | 43 | −£9.1m | Map |
| 14 | St Saviour | 11,311 m² | 40 | −£4.1m | Map |
| 15 | Vale | 10,527 m² | 37 | −£5.4m | Map |
| 16 | Vale | 9,978 m² | 35 | −£5.1m | Map |
| 17 | Castel | 9,848 m² | 34 | −£1.9m | Map |
| 18 | St Sampson's | 8,897 m² | 31 | −£6.5m | Map |
| 19 | Vale | 8,712 m² | 30 | −£4.4m | Map |
| 20 | Vale | 8,317 m² | 29 | −£4.2m | Map |
| 21 | St Sampson's | 7,984 m² | 28 | −£5.9m | Map |
| 22 | Torteval | 7,954 m² | 28 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 23 | St Andrew | 7,894 m² | 28 | −£3.5m | Map |
| 24 | St Sampson's | 7,669 m² | 27 | −£5.7m | Map |
| 25 | Castel | 6,988 m² | 24 | −£1.4m | Map |
| 26 | St Sampson's | 6,623 m² | 23 | −£4.8m | Map |
| 27 | Castel | 6,570 m² | 23 | −£1.3m | Map |
| 28 | St Martin | 6,311 m² | 22 | +£0.6m | Map |
| 29 | Vale | 5,928 m² | 21 | −£3.0m | Map |
| 30 | Vale | 5,875 m² | 21 | −£3.0m | Map |
| 31 | St Peter Port | 5,610 m² | 20 | −£2.5m | Map |
| 32 | St Sampson's | 5,288 m² | 19 | −£4.0m | Map |
| 33 | St Saviour | 5,181 m² | 18 | −£1.9m | Map |
| 34 | Torteval | 5,041 m² | 18 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 35 | Castel | 4,866 m² | 17 | −£1.0m | Map |
| 36 | St Sampson's | 4,809 m² | 17 | −£3.6m | Map |
| 37 | St Saviour | 4,580 m² | 16 | −£1.7m | Map |
| 38 | St Sampson's | 4,368 m² | 15 | −£3.2m | Map |
| 39 | St Peter Port | 4,326 m² | 15 | −£1.9m | Map |
| 40 | Vale | 4,259 m² | 15 | −£2.2m | Map |
| 41 | Castel | 4,184 m² | 15 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 42 | St Andrew | 4,130 m² | 14 | −£1.8m | Map |
| 43 | Vale | 4,017 m² | 14 | −£2.0m | Map |
| 44 | St Martin | 3,964 m² | 14 | +£0.4m | Map |
| 45 | St Sampson's | 3,911 m² | 14 | −£2.9m | Map |
| 46 | Vale | 3,691 m² | 13 | −£1.9m | Map |
| 47 | St Sampson's | 3,688 m² | 13 | −£2.7m | Map |
| 48 | Castel | 3,636 m² | 13 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 49 | St Saviour | 3,615 m² | 13 | −£1.3m | Map |
| 50 | Vale | 3,516 m² | 12 | −£1.8m | Map |
| 51 | St Martin | 3,454 m² | 12 | +£0.3m | Map |
| 52 | Vale | 3,404 m² | 12 | −£1.7m | Map |
| 53 | St Saviour | 3,187 m² | 11 | −£1.1m | Map |
| 54 | Vale | 3,165 m² | 11 | −£1.6m | Map |
| 55 | St Pierre du Bois | 3,092 m² | 11 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 56 | St Saviour | 3,074 m² | 11 | −£1.1m | Map |
| 57 | St Saviour | 3,058 m² | 11 | −£1.1m | Map |
| 58 | Castel | 3,004 m² | 11 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 59 | St Sampson's | 2,904 m² | 10 | −£2.1m | Map |
| 60 | Vale | 2,886 m² | 10 | −£1.5m | Map |
| 61 | St Sampson's | 2,872 m² | 10 | −£2.1m | Map |
| 62 | St Andrew | 2,852 m² | 10 | −£1.3m | Map |
| 63 | St Martin | 2,837 m² | 10 | +£0.3m | Map |
| 64 | St Saviour | 2,740 m² | 10 | −£1.0m | Map |
| 65 | St Sampson's | 2,718 m² | 10 | −£2.1m | Map |
| 66 | Vale | 2,542 m² | 9 | −£1.3m | Map |
| 67 | Vale | 2,482 m² | 9 | −£1.3m | Map |
| 68 | St Sampson's | 2,475 m² | 9 | −£1.9m | Map |
| 69 | St Saviour | 2,447 m² | 9 | −£0.9m | Map |
| 70 | St Pierre du Bois | 2,404 m² | 8 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 71 | St Saviour | 2,401 m² | 8 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 72 | St Pierre du Bois | 2,378 m² | 8 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 73 | St Saviour | 2,365 m² | 8 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 74 | Forest | 2,289 m² | 8 | −£0.5m | Map |
| 75 | Vale | 2,274 m² | 8 | −£1.2m | Map |
| 76 | Castel | 2,250 m² | 8 | −£0.5m | Map |
| 77 | Vale | 2,227 m² | 8 | −£1.2m | Map |
| 78 | St Sampson's | 2,220 m² | 8 | −£1.7m | Map |
| 79 | Castel | 2,196 m² | 8 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 80 | Forest | 2,189 m² | 8 | −£0.5m | Map |
| 81 | St Saviour | 2,162 m² | 8 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 82 | St Saviour | 2,118 m² | 7 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 83 | Forest | 2,117 m² | 7 | −£0.5m | Map |
| 84 | St Martin | 2,113 m² | 7 | +£0.2m | Map |
| 85 | St Saviour | 2,060 m² | 7 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 86 | St Saviour | 2,053 m² | 7 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 87 | Vale | 2,000 m² | 7 | −£1.0m | Map |
| 88 | St Saviour | 1,924 m² | 7 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 89 | Vale | 1,897 m² | 7 | −£1.0m | Map |
| 90 | St Saviour | 1,866 m² | 7 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 91 | Vale | 1,843 m² | 6 | −£0.9m | Map |
| 92 | Vale | 1,836 m² | 6 | −£0.9m | Map |
| 93 | Castel | 1,811 m² | 6 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 94 | St Sampson's | 1,797 m² | 6 | −£1.3m | Map |
| 95 | Vale | 1,795 m² | 6 | −£0.9m | Map |
| 96 | Castel | 1,790 m² | 6 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 97 | Castel | 1,702 m² | 6 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 98 | St Pierre du Bois | 1,680 m² | 6 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 99 | St Saviour | 1,642 m² | 6 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 100 | Vale | 1,572 m² | 6 | −£0.9m | Map |
| 101 | St Pierre du Bois | 1,543 m² | 5 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 102 | Vale | 1,522 m² | 5 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 103 | Torteval | 1,515 m² | 5 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 104 | Vale | 1,492 m² | 5 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 105 | Vale | 1,490 m² | 5 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 106 | St Sampson's | 1,433 m² | 5 | −£1.1m | Map |
| 107 | Vale | 1,419 m² | 5 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 108 | St Pierre du Bois | 1,413 m² | 5 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 109 | Torteval | 1,401 m² | 5 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 110 | Vale | 1,353 m² | 5 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 111 | Vale | 1,342 m² | 5 | −£0.7m | Map |
| 112 | Torteval | 1,328 m² | 5 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 113 | Torteval | 1,285 m² | 4 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 114 | St Pierre du Bois | 1,248 m² | 4 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 115 | Vale | 1,203 m² | 4 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 116 | Vale | 1,190 m² | 4 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 117 | Vale | 1,176 m² | 4 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 118 | St Peter Port | 1,166 m² | 4 | −£0.5m | Map |
| 119 | St Sampson's | 1,156 m² | 4 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 120 | Vale | 1,118 m² | 4 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 121 | Vale | 1,101 m² | 4 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 122 | St Saviour | 1,097 m² | 4 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 123 | St Sampson's | 1,068 m² | 4 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 124 | St Sampson's | 1,065 m² | 4 | −£0.8m | Map |
| 125 | St Pierre du Bois | 1,060 m² | 4 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 126 | Castel | 1,014 m² | 4 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 127 | St Saviour | 968 m² | 3 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 128 | Vale | 918 m² | 3 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 129 | St Sampson's | 915 m² | 3 | −£0.6m | Map |
| 130 | Vale | 889 m² | 3 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 131 | St Pierre du Bois | 882 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 132 | St Martin | 872 m² | 3 | +£0.1m | Map |
| 133 | St Pierre du Bois | 812 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 134 | St Pierre du Bois | 806 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 135 | Vale | 777 m² | 3 | −£0.4m | Map |
| 136 | Castel | 776 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 137 | St Saviour | 773 m² | 3 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 138 | St Pierre du Bois | 770 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 139 | St Pierre du Bois | 738 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 140 | Castel | 718 m² | 3 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 141 | Castel | 700 m² | 2 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 142 | Torteval | 650 m² | 2 | £0.0m | Map |
| 143 | St Saviour | 649 m² | 2 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 144 | St Saviour | 615 m² | 2 | −£0.2m | Map |
| 145 | Forest | 603 m² | 2 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 146 | St Pierre du Bois | 565 m² | 2 | −£0.1m | Map |
| 147 | Vale | 548 m² | 2 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 148 | Vale | 546 m² | 2 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 149 | Vale | 519 m² | 2 | −£0.3m | Map |
| 150 | Vale | 505 m² | 2 | −£0.3m | Map |
Glass is from OpenStreetMap (ODbL), 1 October 2026: buildings within 25 m merged into one site, sites under 500 m² dropped, parishes from OpenStreetMap boundaries. It shows where glass is, not its condition.
The appraisal is physical capacity, not what planning would allow; the realistic yield is a fraction of it. Values come from this site's sale register.